Fishing Ontario's Eagle Lake

Eagle Lake: A Fishing Paradise
Krysten Potega
By Krysten Potega

Krysten Potega is an avid angler and hunter from the State of Wisconsin.

Last Updated: October 24, 2024

An All-Inclusive Experience on Eagle Lake

Nestled on a private island in the heart of Ontario's Sunset Country, Eagle Lake Island Lodge offers an unparalleled fishing experience.  The lodge, situated just a short boat ride from the landing, is perfect for a corporate retreat, family vacation, or hardcore angler to wet a line after a world-class fish. Imagine waking up to the gentle lapping of waves against the shore and the fresh scent of pine. Eagle Lake Island Lodge provides just that. Each cabin offers modern amenities, ensuring your comfort while maintaining the charm of a secluded island getaway. Private screen porches overlooking the lake allow you to relax and soak in the stunning scenery.

Eagle Lake Island Lodge

Delights

One of the perks of the all-inclusive experience is the effortless dining. There is no need to pack lunches or worry about cooking; simply show up at the designated mealtime and savour your meal. The chef carefully curated meals that were both delicious and quick. The lodge's commitment to punctuality ensures youre back on the water and fishing in no time. After fishing all day, there's nothing like relaxing with a cold beverage. Eagle Lake Island Lodge boasts an open bar where you can savour various refreshing drinks while sharing stories with fellow anglers. One of my favourite times at Eagle was visiting the bar after fishing in the evenings to listen to the fishing reports of the day.  

After a day of fishing, it's time for a cold one!

A Fishing Legacy

The crown jewel of Eagle Lake Island Lodge is undoubtedly the fishing. Renowned for its trophy-sized muskies, walleyes, northern pike, smallmouth bass, and lake trout, this pristine lake is an angler's paradise. Experienced and knowledgeable guides are on hand to help you navigate the waters of Eagle Lake, ensuring you have the best possible chance of landing that trophy fish. With their expert guidance, you'll discover hidden fishing spots and learn valuable techniques to maximize your chances of catching the fish of a lifetime.

Northern pike fishing on Eagle Lake

The rental boats are top-of-the-line and equipped with all the necessary gear for a successful day on the water. From comfortable seating and reliable engines to state-of-the-art fishing equipment, these boats are designed to provide a relaxed and enjoyable fishing experience. One of the most significant advantages of fishing at Eagle Lake Island Lodge is the all-inclusive package, which includes unlimited bait and gas. This means you can explore the vast expanse of the lake without worrying about additional costs. 

While Eagle Lake offers exceptional fishing opportunities, it's essential to exercise caution. The lake is known for its rocky bars, which have claimed many lower units and props. Take your time, navigate carefully, and always prioritize safety on the water.  

Catch a trophy walleye in Ontario

We were lucky enough to go with Joe, a seasoned guide from Eagle Lake, who showed us top lure choices, areas to concentrate on, and areas to avoid.  While musky fishing may be what Eagle Lake is known for, don’t snub your nose at the trophy walleye fishing.  We were absolutely blown away at not only the quantity available but the quality of the fish.  In our short stay at Eagle Lake, I broke my personal best Walleye twice! While bottom bouncers with a crawler harness seemed to be the bait of choice for the majority of the anglers, we opted for a 2-3/4 (W7) Jigging Rap in the colours Glow Tiger, Gold, and Glow.

Jiggin raps work great for walleye

Without a shadow of a doubt, I saw more muskies on Eagle Lake than I have in my entire life.  Observing these fish, their reactions to bait, and their curiosity (we had two different muskies come up to check out our trolling motor) made for an unforgettable few days. Whether you're a seasoned angler, a corporate group, or a family looking to create unforgettable memories, Eagle Lake Island Lodge is the perfect destination. With its comfortable accommodations, exceptional dining, open bar, and world-class fishing, this all-inclusive resort promises an unforgettable experience!  P.S make sure to say Hi to the island dogs Daisy and Penny.

pet friendly lodging in Ontario

The best way to start planning a trip is to order a Free Sunset Country Guide & Map.

You can also call the Sunset Country office at 1-800-665-7567 to speak with someone about planning your trip to Canada.

Luxury accommodations at Eagle Lake Island Lodge